Tag Archives: Sun Microsystems

Resistance is Futile: The Oracle Acquisition

The thing to understand about the illumos community is that it started out traumatized: most of us went through the baptism by fire that was the acquisition of Sun Microsystems by Oracle.

My own part in all this was very minor, but I had a ringside seat on larger events. I recount here what I saw; your own memories of this history may, of course, be very different!

Part 1: In the Gloaming

I had started working as a contractor for Sun in March, 2007. They liked me so well that, after a year, they wanted to hire me full-time into the Solaris engineering group, as a social media and community expert. When I got the offer, I called up a friend, a VC in New York who’d been trying to help me find work (not easy, as I was living in Italy at the time).

“I got a job at Sun!” I told him excitedly.

There was a long silence.

“Well,” he finally said, “it’ll look good on your resumé.”

“Huh?”

“Jonathan [Schwartz, Sun’s CEO] has been shopping the company all over Wall Street for nine months. It’s only a matter of time til it’s acquired.”

This did not give me pause. A job with a company on the auction block, back in the US, was still better than poorly-paid work or no work at all in Italy. I’d been through an acquisition before, and did pretty well out of it, though I certainly didn’t get rich. How bad could it be? More to the point: could it be any worse than the career stagnation I was suffering in Italy? I took the risk, left Italy, and went to work for Sun in Colorado. My first day in Sun’s Broomfield office was April 1st, 2008.

It was a shock, but not a surprise, when we heard in March, 2009 – from the media – that Sun might be acquired by IBM. Gloom, doom, and rumors of boom followed – and we were already reeling from round after round of layoffs. After about a month of worrying, we learned that we were, instead, to be acquired by Oracle.

At first blush, this seemed like a better fit and perhaps less overwhelming than IBM. I was cautiously optimistic. An old friend of mine used to work for Oracle and had loved the company, only leaving when she moved with her husband to a city where Oracle didn’t have an office. That had been years before, but I kept an open mind, and set about trying to understand what my life at Oracle might be like.

I was working in two areas – community and social media – where Sun was forward-looking. In employee blogging, Sun was so liberal that the hard part was encouraging employees to be as enthusiastic about it as the CEO.

My video work, though instigated by my managers in engineering, had been harder to “sell” to the official media team at Sun. They wanted all Sun video to show (expensive) professional production values, and were not keen to embrace enthusiastic amateurs like myself. There were stringent guidelines and a multi-week compliance process for the use of the Sun logo. As a result, the most successful video ever made about Sun technology contains no Sun branding at all.*

I was not deterred, and found others who thought as I did about video and podcasts. Sun being the “collection of feuding warlords” that it was, there were eventually three different media hosting platforms made available by various groups within the company, as well as YouTube and blip.tv. Over time I used them all to host my hundreds of technical videos. I knew these to be valuable, and had viewing statistics to prove it, so I was confident that my new colleagues at Oracle could be persuaded.

The acquisition took many months to complete, in part because of an anti-trust investigation by the European Commission. But Oracle was confident of eventual victory, and began dictating changes within Sun well beforehand. And, wherever we lacked concrete knowledge about our future, there were rumors, most of them frightening.

Sun.com was one of the oldest domains on the Internet (one of Sun’s slogans had been “the network is the computer”). Over time it had sprawled to 400 separate sites, a jungle that needed taming – but which also contained an enormous amount of computing industry history.

Suspecting that this status as an Internet historical place would not protect Sun.com, I offered my colleagues this advice based on painful experience.

continues…


*NB: I had nothing to do with this video, and only met its perpetrators later, though I work very closely with them now.


The Last of OpenSolaris

The summer of 2010 was largely a painful mess. I had moved to San Francisco in April, and by late May was very ill with a sinus infection that would eventually require months of antibiotics and two procedures to clear out. On the work side, Sun had been bought by Oracle, and we were in the throes of a merger that caused enormous pain to most former Sun employees.

I had an office in building 18 of Sun’s Menlo Park (MPK) campus, but I didn’t spend much time there. The building already seemed very empty: whole teams had been laid off, and those remaining preferred to work from home so as not to be constantly reminded of those who were gone.

By midsummer, we knew for sure that MPK would be sold and we’d all be moving to Sun’s Santa Clara offices. As a minor part of preparing for the move, I was asked to clear out 10 or so storage rooms that had belonged to various groups. I was ideal for this assignment: I’m very good at sorting and packing. I also hate waste, so I was anxious to find good homes for as much stuff as possible, though this was a lot more work than just “recycling” it all.

First, I took inventory:

  • Over 3000 t-shirts. Most had been made for OpenSolaris user groups (why were there so many for Poland?!?). We were no longer allowed to give these away outside the company, because the OpenSolaris brand had been “deprecated”.
  • Hundreds of baseball caps, also OpenSolaris-logoed. Ditto.
  • A gigantic shipping pallet full of copies of the OpenSolaris Bible. The information in them was (and is) still useful, but, again – wrong branding.
  • Hundreds of copies of Solaris Internals, Solaris Application Programming, and others, but only 28 of Solaris Performance and Tools – which proved to be the most in-demand of the books.
  • Huge amounts of office supplies, which we gave to a program that gives this stuff to teachers.

There were a few unique items, such as Solaris-logoed boxer shorts. Thousands of plastic license plate frames intended for a dismally-failed promo for the Sun cloud (nothing to do with these but put them in the recycle bin).

^ I found two of these robots in a closet that had belonged to the Java team. Online research showed that they had been part of one of Gosling‘s toy shows at JavaOne some years before. They came home with me; one has since gone on to pursue a career in Hollywood, the other is at the Joyent offices (matches the decor) went to live with Ben Rockwood’s family. I assume that Number 3 still lives with Gosling.

And OpenSolaris-labelled champagne:

I remembered this: it had been served at a party during CommunityOne in 2008. Lynn and I snagged a case of the remainders to take back to our colleagues in Broomfield. The case or so that I later found in a store room in MPK we served at a farewell-to-MPK party in August, 2010.

Making endless trips between buildings with trolleys full of heavy boxes, I consolidated all the books and apparel into one large storage room. Then I advertised within the company to find “buyers.” To my surprise, everyone wanted an OpenSolaris shirt. None had been given out within the company: only people who had attended conferences and user group events had them. Which left out most of the engineers who had actually created (Open)Solaris! So I packed up dozens of shirts to send to Sun offices around the world. I took piles of stuff to the engineering meetings that I attended as part of my regular job – which turned out to be a good way to warm up engineers who were previously too shy to even speak to me.

But there was still a lot of stuff left. Towards the end of summer, when I was on a deadline to get Building 18 cleared, I started having lunchtime “store hours” when people could come rifle through piles of shirts and pick up books.

An Oracle VP of software drove down from Redwood Shores to get copies of Solaris Internals for his team – said he didn’t have budget to buy them. ???

Dozens of people came to grab some remnants of Sun history. There were historic encounters, such as the above meeting in my storeroom/showroom between Solaris book authors Darryl Gove and Brendan Gregg.

Some of the schwag has had interesting later lives. Several dozen hats went to a church, to help keep people together during a hike in Yosemite. Another bunch ended up at a school event, and are still seen on that campus today. I gave a hat to a friend who had nothing to do with Solaris, but now gets chatted up by random geeks in San Francisco whenever she wears it.

^ One of the largest things we kept was this 40-foot banner, which we later used to decorate a Solaris Family Reunion.

While the last of the OpenSolaris branding was thus being purged from Sun/Oracle, two significant things happened for the future of the technology itself:

(More history and what happened next is here.)


 

Part 1: Resistance is Futile: The Oracle Acquisition

Part 2: What to Expect When You’re Expecting – to Be Acquired

Part 3: Fishworks and Me

Part 4: Into the Belly of the Beast

Part 5: The Last of OpenSolaris

Coda: Letting Go of a Beloved Technology

The Faces of Sun

I’ve been meaning for a long time to make a video tribute to the amazing people of Sun Microsystems. It has been my honor and privilege to work with some of the finest minds in this industry (or any industry), many of whom I also got to film at Sun conferences and other events worldwide.

While it’s breaking my heart to witness the diaspora of Sun talent, I take comfort in knowing that, in new companies with new projects, these folks will cause a thousand new technologies to bloom. I look forward to seeing what everyone gets up to – including those who remain at Oracle – and hope you’ll all stay in touch and keep me posted. Though a situation like Sun may be unique and unrepeatable, I expect I’ll work with you again someday.

Most of the footage shown here I shot myself over three years, in varying conditions and with varying equipment. A few of these clips are someone else’s footage that I post-produced or edited. A few of the more engaging clips were created by the teams participating in the Go Game during the OpenSolaris Developers’ Summit held in 2008. Those aren’t my work, but – if you’ve got footage of David Korn dancing, you use it! (No, he was not a Sun employee; there are a few other “friends of” in here as well.)

The photos are mostly mine. I chose the song primarily for its bouncy and variable tempo, so if you find yourself juxtaposed with an unflattering lyric, don’t take it personally – it wasn’t intentional. Apologies to the many who were left out – I have too much material for one three-minute song! If you’re neither in the video nor in the Missing list below, let me know in the comments and I’ll add you.

Dec 28, 2010 – Have started updating the lists below with “where are they now” information – feel free to add comments if you know something I don’t! (And can add people who aren’t on these lists.)

Starring

in order of appearance
  • (Bruno Souza) at OSCON 2009 – Brazilian government?
  • Dominic Kay at SNIA SNW 2008 – Oracle
  • Tim Thomas at Sun’s London office, Jan 2009 – ?
  • Valerie Bubb Fenwick at OSCON 2009- Oracle
  • Cindy Swearingen at Sun’s Broomfield campus, Jan 2010- Oracle
  • John Sonnenschein, Go Game at the Open Solaris Developers’ Summit, Santa Cruz, 2008 – Joyent
  • John Fowler at SC08, Austin- Oracle
  • Andy Bechtolsheim at SC08, Austin – Arista
  • Rick Ramsey & Darren Moffat at OOW10 – Oracle
  • Rossella Laeng & April Hall at SC08, Austin – n/a
  • Jeff Jackson celebrating Mardi Gras at Sun’s Menlo Park campus, 2009 – ?
  • Josh Simons at SC08, Austin – ?
  • Sara Dornsife at the Open Solaris Developers’ Summit 2008 – PayPal
  • Sunay Tripathi at the Security Summit at LISA09 – ?
  • Roch Bourbonnais at Sun’s San Francisco office, March 2010- Oracle
  • George Wilson in San Francisco, July 2010 – Delphix
  • Constantin Gonzalez at the Open Solaris Developers’ Summit 2009- Oracle
  • Niall Power at Sun’s Dublin office, Jan 2009
  • Dan Templeton, Miha Ahronovitz, Gregory Shirin at SC08, Austin- Oracle
  • Mike Shapiro & Steve O’Grady in San Francisco, Sept 2008 – ?, still at RedMonk
  • Rich Breuckner SC09 – InsideHPC (owner)
  • Mark Cruciani & Margaret Hamburger in Sun’s Eagan office – ?, Oracle
  • Drew Wilson & Sherry Menne celebrating Mardi Gras at Sun’s Menlo Park campus 2009 – Oracle
  • Diana Wadding, Tina Hartshorn, Wendy Ames at the Open Storage Summit 2009 – Oracle
  • ? & Jerry Jelinek at CommunityOne 2009 – Jerry’s at Joyent
  • Margaret Hamburger & Matthew Baier in Broomfield – Oracle
  • Brendan Gregg at Fishworks 2010 – Joyent
  • Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva, Rafael Vanoni, Vitorio Sassi at FISL, Porto Alegre, Brazil, 2009 – President of Brazil, ?, ?
  • Jeff Bonwick, Bryan Cantrill playing the marker game at Sun’s Menlo Park campus, 2010 – mystery startup, Joyent
  • Roma Baron at Sun’s Menlo Park campus, 2010 – Oracle
  • Bryan Cantrill at LISA09 – Joyent
  • Sumit Gupta at Sun’s Broomfield campus, 2007 – ?
  • Lori Alt at Sun’s Broomfield campus, 2008 – Oracle
  • Jeff Cheeney, Reed, ? at SNW 2008 – ?
  • Adam Leventhal at the Open Storage Summit 2009 – Delphix
  • Dave Miner at the Solaris Summmit at LISA10 – Oracle
  • Peter Bojanic at the HPC Consortium 2008 – ?
  • Dale Layfield at SC09
  • Larry McIntosh at SC09
  • Terri Wischmann at the Open Storage Summit 2008 – Oracle
  • Chris Horne at Sun’s Broomfield campus, 2007
  • Dan Roberts at Sun’s Menlo Park campus, 2010 – dev tools company
  • Chris Armes at Sun’s Menlo Park campus, 2010 – Oracle
  • Bill Nesheim at Sun’s Menlo Park campus, 2010 – Oracle
  • Bill Pijewski, Mike Harsch at Sun’s Broomfield campus, 2010 – Joyent
  • Thorsten Freauf at Sun’s Menlo Park campus, 2008 – Oracle
  • Mayuresh Nirhali at Tech Days, Hyderabad, 2010; Paul Needle at Sun’s London office, 2009 – Oracle
  • Prasad Pai at the HPC Consortium 2008 – Oracle
  • Cristiano Basso & Brian Leonard at FISL 2009 – ?, Oracle
  • Lynn Rohrer, Simon Phipps, fan at FISL 2009 – Oracle, Forgerock
  • FISL attendees 2009
  • Arun Gupta, Eduardo Lima, Mauricio Leal at FISL 2009 – Oracle, ?, ?
  • Alan DuBoff et al Go Game at the Open Solaris Developers’ Summit 2008 – ?
  • Dan Maslowski & Scott Tracy at CommunityOne 2009- Oracle
  • Scott Rotondo at OSCON 2009- Oracle
  • Dennis Maher at the Security Summit at LISA09- Oracle
  • Ashu Tripathi at the Open Source Grid & Cluster Conference 2008- Oracle
  • Bruno Souza & Jack Adams at OSCON 2009
  • Juergen Schleich at home 2009
  • Simon Phipps, Charlie Boyle, Angel Camacho in Porto Alegre, Brazil 2009 – Forgerock, Oracle, EMC
  • Java fans with Roger Brinkley at FISL 2009
  • Teresa Giacomini at FISL 2009- Oracle
  • Tim Bray & Bryan Cantrill at OOW09 – Google, Joyent
  • Durjoy Mazumdar at OOW09- Oracle
  • Joost Pronk at OOW10- Oracle
  • Darren Moffat at the Security Summit at LISA09- Oracle
  • Liane Praza, Dave Miner, Bart Smaalders, Dan Price, Dan Roberts at LISA10- Oracle, except for Dan R.
  • Markus Flierl at the Solaris Summmit at LISA10- Oracle
  • Liane Praza at the Solaris Summmit at LISA10- Oracle
  • Glenn Faden at the Solaris Summmit at LISA10- Oracle
  • Nicolas Droux at the Solaris Summmit at LISA10- Oracle
  • Ellard Roush at the Security Summit at LISA09- Oracle
  • Art Licht at the Open Road to Storage, Broomfield, 2009- Oracle
  • Alex Barclay at the Laureate Institute for Brain Research, Sept 2009
  • Meenakshi Kaul-Basu at Sun’s Menlo Park campus 2008- Oracle
  • Gia-Khanh Nguyen at Sun’s Menlo Park campus 2008- Oracle
  • Graham Scattergood at Sun’s London office 2009
  • Jim Mauro (stunt) & Dan Price at LISA10- Oracle
  • Jack Adams & Nick Solter at OSCON 2009 – ?, Context Optional
  • Diana Wadding at Sun’s Broomfield campus 2009- Oracle
  • OSUG Leaders, Tim Marsland at CommunityOne 2009 – ?
  • Kelly Nishimura & Bill Franklin at CommunityOne 2009 – ?, ?
  • Joy Marshall, Frank Lindquist, Lynn Rohrer at CommunityOne 2009- Oracle, ?, Oracle
  • Bruno Souza & Aaron Newcomb at FISL 2009 – ?, Oracle
  • David Gwynne & Garrett D’Amore at the Kernel Conference Australia 2009 – ?, Nexenta
  • Kris Hake at CommunityOne 2009
  • Lynn Rohrer at FISL 2009- Oracle
  • Christoph Schuba at the Security Summit at LISA09- Oracle
  • Drew Wilson at LISA08- Oracle
  • Fritz Ferstl at the Open Source Grid & Cluster Conference 2008
  • Jeff Bonwick & Bill Moore at SNIA 2008, maybe – mystery startup (both of them)
  • ? & David Korn Go Game at the Open Solaris Developers’ Summit 2008
  • Ben Rockwood & Deirdré Straughan at LISA09 – Joyent
  • Kuldip Oberoi & Don Kretsch at Sun’s Menlo Park campus 2010- Oracle
  • Jim Mauro at Sun’s San Francisco office 2010- Oracle
  • Brendan Gregg at Fishworks 2010 – Joyent
  • Jeff Cheeney, Jim Grisanzio, Michelle Luna, Chris Baker Go Game at the Open Solaris Developers’ Summit 2008 – ?, Oracle, Oracle, Oracle
  • Harriet Coverston at the SAM-QFS BoF at SC09 – ?
  • Brendan Gregg at Sun’s Broomfield campus, FROSUG Oct 2009 – “Who turned out the lights?”

Missing

People I have actually filmed but could not lay hands on the footage, or there just wasn’t room for it (this list is destined to grow). Some of these videos are were for a time available on blogs.sun.com/video, others were lost in the move to Oracle (not by me!). A lot of the video I shot for Sun/Oracle (and more) is on my YouTube channel.

  • Aaron Dailey- Oracle
  • John Forte- Oracle
  • Jim Dunham
  • Spencer Shepler
  • Robert Thurlow- Oracle
  • Mark Carlson- Oracle
  • …and a bunch of others at SNIA SDC 2007. And 2008.
  • Stephen S. Teppler Esq.
  • Glynn Foster- Oracle
  • the NWAM team- Oracle
  • Peter Karlsson- Oracle
  • Philip Torchinsky- Oracle
  • Bill Nesheim- Oracle
  • …and several others at Tech Days Hyderabad
  • Charles Baker- Oracle
  • Clay Baenziger- Oracle
  • Arnaud Lacour – ?
  • …and others at various editions of FROSUG
  • James McPherson- Oracle
  • Max Bruning – Joyent
  • Sherry Moore- Oracle
  • Gavin Maltby
  • …and others at the Kernel Conference Australia 2009

For more nostalgia, see Jim Grisanzio’s beautiful album of OpenSolaris community photos (yes, I’m in there, too).

 
 

Geek Humor

Storagetek’s Broomfield, CO, headquarters was abundantly decorated with artwork. After Sun acquired the company, everyone moved to Sun’s BRM campus, and eventually the Storagetek building was closed down. The artwork appeared overnight in the BRM offices. I don’t know who decided where to put it all, but our floor (engineering) got lots of photographs of objects in space.

Naturally, someone couldn’t resist a caption on this one.